Friday, March 30, 2012

Withdrawal talks heat up in Arundel

Residents discuss benefits and drawbacks of leaving RSU 21

Arundel residents met to discuss possible benefits and repercussions of passing a petition that will allow the town to withdraw from Regional School Unit 21.

For two and half hours, the board and approximately 90 members of the public listened to various opinions from Arundel residents about whether the withdrawal petition should pass.

Those in favor of the petition and who want Arundel to leave the district said the petition will help save on overall costs and regain control of spending. Those in opposition of the petition are worried education will falter if Arundel severs ties with the district. RSU 21 consists of Arundel, Kennebunk and Kennebunkport.

On April 10, Arundel residents will have the opportunity to vote on whether they will ultimately leave the district. According to Rep. Wayne Parry of District 140, Arundel only needs 50 percent plus one vote to either pass or oppose the petition because of a recent law change that adjusted the ratio from a two-thirds majority to simple majority vote. District 140 is made up of Arundel, Dayton, part of Kennebunk and part of Lyman.
“It is 50 percent plus one, but you need a minimum of 50 percent of (people who voted in) the last gubernatorial election to come and vote,” said Parry, adding that the statute prevents a small number of voters from deciding major decisions in the town.

“There will have to be approximately 950 people turn out to vote in favor,” said Arundel Town Manager Todd Shea, when asked by a member of the public exactly how many votes would be needed.

If the petition passes, it would allow municipal officers to use no more than $35,000 to form a withdrawal committee designed to explore future education options with the help of unbiased advisors. The withdrawal committee would consist of one municipal officer, one member of the public and one member from those who initially filed the petition, Shea said.

read more...

Thursday, March 29, 2012

APRIL 10th VOTE | 8:00am - 8:00pm

To ALL ARUNDEL RESIDENTS:

The following information was submitted by the
The Save Arundel Group and other Concerned Arundel Citizens
for Public Viewing.

~ What you need to know before the April 10th vote ~

Dear Friends and Neighbors,

~ About the FIRST vote on April 10th  ~ 
  • Voting YES is not a vote against EDUCATION!
  • Voting YES is not a vote for withdrawal of the RSU!
  • Voting YES will allow an independent study to be done that will give all of us information we are so desperately looking for.
  • Voting YES will also allow us to form a Withdrawal Committee to create a plan to withdraw. This is a mandatory step of the withdrawal process, mandated by the State of Maine.
There will only be one question on the Ballot. Please see below.
If the yes vote does not pass, then it will be two years before another petition can be signed to withdraw from the RSU.
 
~ Ballot for April 10th ~
It will be stated like this:
Do you favor filing a petition for withdrawal with the Board of Directors of Regional School Unit 21 and with the Commissioner of Education, authorizing the Withdrawal Committee to expend $35,000 and authorizing the Board of Selectman to issue notes in the name of the Town of Arundel or other-wise pledge the credit of the Town of Arundel in an amount not to exceed $35,000 for this purpose?

Yes  X               No ____

Note: Absentee ballots are available now at the town hall and remember no absentee voting is allowed three business days before the election ***

~ About the Second and Final vote ~
(This will only occur if we win the April 10th Vote)
THIS IS THE VOTE THAT WILL DETERMINE IF WE WITHDRAW FROM THE RSU21 OR NOT.
We will ALL have the information we need to make an informed decision before the final vote.
The Maine State Board of Education will approve the plan before it can go to a vote, so the Town will know this a solid plan.
We would LOVE to have this vote take place during the presidential election in November, but this may be an aggressive timeline.

~ About the $35,000 ~
Arundel’s Board of Selectman came up with this figure that needs to be voted on April 10th. This is the breakdown:

$12,000 Consultant Fee/Study (This may change)
This is for a study from an unbiased group to determine if withdrawal is the right move for our town. The Board of Selectman feels this is necessary to ensure citizens make the right decision on withdrawal from the RSU21.
Page 1.
$15,000 Legal Counsel
Attorney work, negotiations, etc.

$ 8,000 Buffer
This is for unexpected cost/overages, such as the consultant fee.

This money would be taken from the ‘Undesignated Funds’ for our town which has MILLIONS of dollars in it.

The $35,000 is a very SMALL fraction of these funds and is ESSENTIAL to the giving us the information we need to make an informed decision.

A few important side notes:
All this money may not be needed.
Any of this money not spent will stay in the undesignated funds account.


~ Here’s What You Need to Know ~
When we joined with RSU 21:
We gave them a Quit Claim Deed to our school for $0.
We gave them 6 buses, one of which was brand new, for $0.
We gave them approximately $460,000 of Arundel taxpayer’s carry forward money.
We gave them $95,000 of Arundel’s tax dollars refunded from federal contingency money.
Our mold issues at ML Day were REMEDIATED and PAID for.
Our school and busses were PAID for and we had $0 in debt.
Our Arundel school board negotiated with Thornton Academy to provide us with a brand new middle school that is state of the art for nothing more than the state minimum tuition to Arundel tax payers.
Again $0 debt to Arundel taxpayers.
(I think we can all agree- Arundel did a LOT of things right.)

We were told the TAMS contract would not be affected, yet as we all know it was
in serious jeopardy last year.

Note: One of the buses we gave the RSU21 had to be decommissioned.

Since we have joined with RSU 21:

We have NO CONTROL over how the money is spent in the school district, yet
approximately 75% of our taxes are spent on schooling our children.
The Supporters of the RSU say we have three elected officials on the RSU21 School Board and they are OUR VOICE. Unfortunately, three votes out of twelve gets Arundel NO WHERE!

They mention our strong voting influence- An example of this would be Arundel has voted down EVERY school budget since we have been involved in RSU21, yet it passes every year. This is NOT voting power for Arundel.
We have taken on New Debt for problems that occurred, prior to us joining RSU 21. With just the Middle School of the Kennebunks (MSK) alone we will be paying $16,000 for 10 years.
 
Some Budget Information-
To offset the increase in the school budget, other town departments were cut, so taxes would not be increased. (This cannot continue).
To offset the increase in the school budget, a surplus in the undesignated funds was used, so taxes would not be increased.
Our taxes have gone up every year at a disproportional rate compared to Kennebunk and Kennebunkport.

A few notes on the RSU Supporters Handout-
The numbers used on their handout were the original numbers that they wanted to put in the Arrow. The numbers were produced by Jack Reetz (Pro RSU21 Arundel Rep and Andrew Dolloff RSU21 Superintendant). These numbers were reviewed by Todd Shea (our town manager) and he could NOT VERIFY them and therefore could not use them.
Please take a moment to look at the figures posted in the Arrow verses the numbers they passed out to you.
Please also note in 2009, we were part of the RSU21, yet this figure was added to the Pre-RSU side with a massive increase.

~ Here’s What We Do Know ~

After April 10th, it would be too late to back out and not be on the hook for the money spent by RSU 21- the biggest expense being the high school renovations.

Arundel has high school choice, yet only 6% of Kennebunk High School students are from Arundel. Why would we want to pay to renovate a high school that so few of our children attend plus tuition, when all we need to pay for is tuition?

Note: At this time Arundel students cannot attend MSK without paying tuition, but this will change once the contract with TAMS expires in 2016. If we do not withdraw from the RSU21, the RSU21 will have the say as to whether they will sign a new contract with Thornton Academy and we all know this will not happen. Last year was the proof of this.

Arundel has a GREAT deal with TAMS. Our children get a top notch education for the state minimum tuition. If TAMS needs renovating, Arundel tax payers pay $0.

Note: There is a waiting list to get into TAMS. This and the overwhelming vote that
took place last year supporting TAMS is a clear indication that TAMS is a school of excellence that we are extremely fortunate to be a part of.

People move to Arundel for high school choice and now they move to Arundel so their children can attend TAMS.

An article to the Editor said that three towns paying for our school is better than one town paying for the school. This statement would be true if we were the Town of Kennebunk. Their high school needs massive renovations and then there are still the unknowns with MSK.

There are always going to be unknowns, but we think we are safer taking chances with our one school rather than taking a chance on six schools. Remember the looming High School renovations and issues at MSK (these are just two of the six schools).

~ NECAP Test Scores ~
There is a lot of hype on test scores since we merged with the RSU. The State of Maine is moving away from these tests and moving to a national exam. More information can be found on the Maine State Board of Education’s website.

In 2009, the state switched from MEA’s to NECAP’s, so these kids are also testing with different tests.

~ About ML Day School ~

Staff and Salary Increases
There is no question that today ML Day is a better school than it was a few years ago. That credit goes to Dr. Crowley and his amazing staff. The amazing staff that Dr. Crowley is always praising are primarily our teachers from before the RSU21. Many of these teachers have been teaching at ML Day for years, even decades.

Note: This District (RSU21) has some of the highest paid teachers in the State of Maine.
In order for our Arundel teachers to make what the other teachers did in the district, they had to have raises of $8,000- $12,000 each. This was an increase of $170,000 in just salaries alone.

Maintaining Quality Education
There is no question that Dr. Crowley and his team of very fine teachers have improved
the quality of education for our children. We had the great teachers but were lacking the leadership we have now.

To maintain our quality of education, we need to:

  1. Have STRONG leadership. 
  2. Maintain these salaries and insurances for our
    teachers- it would be unfair to take this away from them now.
  3. Stay in compliance with State mandated programs
  4. Work closely with our teachers and see what has worked
    and improve upon what hasn’t.

Programs that were cut
You always hear about what the RSU21 has brought to our schools, but you don’t hear what was taken away. They brought in Spanish but many other things were cut back. Some of them were:
Physical Education- obesity is horrible problem for our youth in this country
Music- we had a teacher that offered FREE lessons after school and was dedicated to her kids and her program
Art
Guidance
Computer Class

Note: Spanish is taught for one hour a week K-5. Perhaps we can pay this same teacher
for her time at ML Day and then Spanish can continue.

The Facility
Repairs done by the RSU included work to the exterior, water and heating system, interior finishes which included a new office and principal office, and landscaping. (See attachment)

The road entering into the school was repaved by the Town of Arundel, not the RSU21.

Including renovations and technology improvements-
the RSU has spent $227,602.


Remember we gave them over half a million dollars
when we joined the RSU.



VOTE YES! on APRIL 10th, 2012 8:00am - 8:00pm


Attachments:
MLD Facilities II



ARUNDEL — A proposal was made to rebuild the sign marking the Donald E. Gilliam Memorial Field at the Board of Selectmen meeting held on Tuesday, March 27.

Jenn Dumas, parks and recreation director, and Roger Taschereau, public works director, spoke on behalf of the concept to rebuild a safer, newer sign that would last longer than the one built in 1980 in memoriam of Donald E. Gilliam III, an Arundel boy who was killed by a car.

Dumas said the sign "hasn't stood the test of time" and also proposed that the sign be moved closer to the field , though he said one issue with that is that people might assume both fields were in dedication to Gilliam.

"If someone comes up with a complaint about that, they have way too much time on their hands," Vice Chairman Mark Paulin said.

Asking for $1,800 from the Board of Selectmen to cover expenses to purchase the sign for cost from Prescott Metal in Biddeford, Selectman Dana Peck, owner of Maine Heritage Ironworks, advised the board to use another finish instead of powder coating.
As it turned out, the town didn't need to pay for the sign. Selectman Phil Labbe offered a donation of $1,000 on behalf of his company, Labbe Excavating, and Paulin made a donation of $250 from his company, Paulin Tire and Auto Care. Others in the room quickly jumped to help raise the needed $1,800.

Community News

The Arundel Historical Society will host an auction in May and is in need for items for the event.
Auction items will be accepted through the middle of April. Proceeds from the auction benefit the Arundel Historical Society.

To donate or for more information, call Dana at 286-4928, Joanne at 985-3087 or Suzanne at 282-3451

Arundel vote is first step in withdrawal


To the editor:
There will be a vote in Arundel on April 10 to allocate $35,000 from the undesignated funds to determine if withdrawal from Regional School Unit 21 is the right move for Arundel.

This money will not increase taxes and will be used to pay a consultant ($12,000), attorney ($8,000) and buffer ($8,000) for unexpected costs. Any sums not used will be returned to the fund.

The reasons for withdrawing are evident and numerous. Arundel provided a deed to its school for no consideration, six buses (one new) which were paid in full, $460,000 in carry forward money and $95,000 of tax dollars refunded from federal contingency money.

Arundel has had a disproportionate increase in taxes compared to Kennebunk and, especially, Kennebunkport. To offset the increase in the school budget and not increase taxes, other town departments were cut and a surplus in the undesignated funds was used, simply postponing the problem.

Before the consolidation with Arundel, Middle School of the Kennebunks has been dealing with an ongoing mold issue.

Arundel at this time must pay $16,000 for the next 10 years. A million-dollar roof still has not resolved the issue.

read more...

Both sides presented at withdrawal hearing



ARUNDEL — Residents gathered to discuss the issue of possible withdrawal from the RSU 21 on Monday, March 26, at Mildred L. Day School.

Following the procedure for a Board of Selectmen meeting, Chairwoman Velma Jones Hayes opened the dialogue by cautioning all residents to fact check and to contact town staff and RSU representatives from Arundel with questions.

"We all want to make sure our kids get the best education," Hayes said in her opening statement.

Town Manager Todd Shea stated that the potential withdrawal process is a "serious matter" and he hopes "people can vote with their conscience."

Monday, March 26, 2012

TOWN OF ARUNDEL, MAINE BOARD OF SELECTMEN MEETING

Monday, March 26, 2012
Mildred L. Day Gymnasium
 
7:00 PM
 
Agenda
 
I. Call to order
 
II. Approval of Agenda
 
III. PUBLIC HEARING ON 20-A MRS §1466, WITHDRAWAL OF A SINGLE MUNICIPALITY FROM A REGIONAL SCHOOL UNIT, AND THE CITIZEN INITIATED PETITION TO WITHDRAW FROM RSU # 21. a) Explanation of withdrawal statute and process b) Explanation of $35,000 request to be voted on by secret ballot on Tuesday, April 10, 2012 c) PUBLIC FORUM
 
IV. Other Business and Adjournment

CALCULATE YOUR TAX INCREASE for the proposed school projects

RSU 21 Building Project Impact Calculator

The RSU Facilities Committee has recommended significant upgrades to Mildred L. Day School, at an early-estimated cost of $3.7M.  A similar proposal to refurbish Kennebunkport Consolidated School has been estimated at $4.2M, while a complete renovation of Kennebunk High School is projected to cost $46.3M.  By entering data from your 2012 tax bill into the chart, below, you may determine the approximate impact of such each, or all, of these projects on your tax bill during the highest year of repayment of this 20 year bond.






Compare the following: