Thursday, June 21, 2012

Speech sparks debate KHS teacher tells students to "tolerate intolerance" in grad day address



KENNEBUNK — A teacher's commencement address at Kennebunk High School's June 10 graduation ceremony has angered some in the community who say it condoned bigotry and ruined the day for some graduates and their families.

The address, made by KHS economics teacher Sean Watson, has sparked a wide range of responses, from those who said they were left "appalled" to others who stand behind the challenge presented in the speech. The speech resulted in e-mails and calls to KHS and RSU 21 administrators from parents and students offended by its content, and earlier this week caused Superintendent Andrew Dolloff to respond with an e-mail to the district community and prompted a heated discussion at Monday's RSU 21 Board of Directors meeting.

In the address, Watson attempted to challenge and present though-provoking questions to the students in a way that turned political, ultimately telling the students to "tolerate intolerance," seemingly arguing against affirmative action, and questioning forms of government.

"I'm arguing that affirmative action is unfair to bigots, and even bigots have a right to be treated fairly," Watson said in the speech. "I disapprove, and I hope every one of you disapproves of bigotry. But the private virtue of tolerance and the public virtue of tolerance require us to tolerate things, which we do not approve. (This speech perhaps.)"

When reached, Watson referred to Dolloff's letter and declined to make any other comments.

No comments:

Post a Comment